Amanda's Bakery

we stopped in to amanda’s bakery today for the first time. we tried several different items as we weren’t sure what would be her specialty but I have to say everything was amazing from the rainbow cookies to a lobster tail pastry which was probably the best i’ve ever tasted! A very happy addition to Bayshore

I live right down the street from Amanda’s Bakery in Bay Shore and could not be happier to live so close! Finally we have an amazing bakery in the town! Everything I have tried has been a 10/10.. from the pies to cakes to breads to a custom black and white cookie order for my friends baby! I just love this place!! I met Amanda the owner when she first opened up and she was so kind and thankful for our business! highly recommend!

I reached out to Amanda’s bakery two days before my daughters first photo shoot session to see if she was able to make me a cake. She responded quickly and made my daughters adorable cake. I couldn’t be happier. Price was great also. Thank you!! ????

Torrie Rogers opted not to leave a text review of Amanda's Bakery

Lori K. opted not to leave a text review of Amanda's Bakery

christy raphael opted not to leave a text review of Amanda's Bakery

Great Bakery, friendly staff and great donuts!

There cheese danish, cakes and canoles were absolutely delicious. Would recommend anyone reading this or in the area to give them try. Also, their service is really good Anadi is a sweetheart.

I highly recommend Amanda’s bakery for their quality and delicious cakes, specialty pies and variety of treats for every season and make your own cookie kits. My kids especially adore their cupcakes, cake pops & rainbow cakes. My family and I loved ordering from them because it is always a good experience getting ready for a special occasion without having to deal with unnecessary hassles, their staff is courteous, punctual, friendly & their location is accessible. They deliver the most exquisite and custom made cakes that look like masterpiece arts. They give the ultimate magical touch to our events. I love their superb professionalism and would always look forward to our next event just to have another piece of Amanda’s bakery cake.

Amanda's Bakery is my favorite bakery. The cakes are always so delicious and fresh, and the service is amazing! I can always rely on them for all my treats!