Reviews from around the web:
|
|
eating clouds
Yesterday I went to Papardalle on Columbus Avenue. Since I returned from my trip to Italy a few months ago I have been in search of some great Italian...
From
citysearch.com on
5/30/2007
Report as offensive
|
|
One of my favorite places!
Pappardella... I love this place. The flat noodle that the restaurant is named after is made in the house freshly every day. There are several choices...
From
menupages.com on
5/3/2007
Report as offensive
|
|
Exactly what we wanted.
Dark and cozy Italian joint. We don't like to be rushed and/or constantly hounded by our waiters... and I'm a fairly picky eater. Very surprised that ...
From
menupages.com on
4/5/2007
Report as offensive
|
|
Not recommended for delivery
We have ordered from this restaurant several times before without any issues. That was until the other night. We waited for over an hour before we cal...
From
menupages.com on
2/10/2007
Report as offensive
|
|
Disappointed.
Nice looking and sounding menu, cozy surroundings...but...our waitress had no personality whatsoever, didn't smile once, and most importantly...the fo...
From
menupages.com on
1/13/2007
Report as offensive
|
|
Owned by Indian Restaurant next door!
I found out this place is owned by the Indian restaurant next door! That explains why the food does not taste like authentic Italian. Since this place...
From
menupages.com on
12/27/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
What a disappointment
After reading the reviews posted here we thought that Pappardella would offer a great Italian meal but it didn't pan out. On the plus side, the restau...
From
menupages.com on
12/4/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
Salty-Salty-Salty
After reading the reviews here, I decided to try out Pappardella. Disappointed is the best way for me to describe the experience. After sitting down S...
From
menupages.com on
12/3/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
Delicious
I went to dinner at Pappardella tonight and it was amazing! The mussels were in a delicious tomato/wine sauce and the lobster ravioli were fantastic! ...
From
menupages.com on
11/22/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
Best Around
While delivery may be lacking I have always found this place to be on top of their game for many years. First time I went was over 10 years ago and st...
From
menupages.com on
11/7/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
Delivery not recommended
This place advertises delivery but every time I call they tell me that there is no delivery that night. I have offered to come pick it up and still I ...
From
menupages.com on
10/26/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
Great Great Pasta
I have ordered a few times from Pappardella and each time has been better than the next. I saw the other review and the delivery was a little slow onc...
From
menupages.com on
10/15/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
The best Italian EVER!
My mom and I went to New York for 4 days, and the first night we came across Pappardella. The food was AMAZING (i got the pizza, my mom got the gnocci...
From
citysearch.com on
9/28/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
Delivery not recommended
I would normally never leave a review, but I do read them for insight. This restuarant is not recommended for delivery: 1) tell me its 30 mins and its...
From
menupages.com on
9/25/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
Bad bar
If you're going for a nice dinner and drinks, skip the drinks at this place. My girlfriend and I ordered drinks from the bar while waiting for the tab...
From
menupages.com on
9/3/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
Nice Charm
Great place to enjoy a meal on a patio. Food is good, service is average. Enjoy a over-priced glass of Sangiovese and just relax and people-watch as y...
From
menupages.com on
8/19/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
Nice neighborhood place.
I have been to Pappardella numerous times and have always had a good dining experience. I have had fish on a few occasions, and my boyfriend has had s...
From
menupages.com on
7/23/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
Nice From the Outside
A friend and I went here the other night after a show. The place was cute and had nice, friendly decor. The food started out OK with an excellent cucu...
From
menupages.com on
7/15/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
They make you feel like family
We have been visiting this UWS gem religiously for the last 2 years and have always left smiling. They treat us like family and when I look around I s...
From
menupages.com on
6/6/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
Awesome!
This is a fabulous place...everyone loved their food, the service was great, fairly roomy dining room for new york. I will most definitely be back man...
From
menupages.com on
3/12/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
Best Neighborhood Italian Place...
My husband and I have been coming here for years. The food is consistently good and the atmosphere is really nice. Love the exposed brick walls and di...
From
menupages.com on
1/31/2006
Report as offensive
|
|
Great neighborhood restaurant
The wait staff is friendly, although not always the fastest. The food is quite good. The atmosphere is very pleasant....
From
menupages.com on
11/9/2005
Report as offensive
|
|
Lovely!
I love to dine here, every time the food is excellent and tasty. Their wine list is paired excellently to the foods on the menu. Good for a snack, too...
From
menupages.com on
9/8/2005
Report as offensive
|
|
Perfect way to end a fabulous weekend!
Less than a block away from our hotel we landed in this JEWEL! We had been on the move all day, tired and not dressed for the evening...welcomed and s...
From
menupages.com on
8/11/2005
Report as offensive
|
|
Not recommended
Over-rated place. The food was tasteless. They even managed to get the ravioli (yes, plain old ravioli) wrong....
From
menupages.com on
7/25/2005
Report as offensive
|
|
Best reasonable UWS traditional Italian
New outdoor seating is great for a nice Summer night outdoor meal. Inside ambience is very as you'd expect Italian, but very nice with good lighting a...
From
citysearch.com on
6/12/2005
Report as offensive
|
|
Best pasta in Manhattan
After months of looking for a good Italian place and we finally found it! And believe me we had search. This place on the upper west side has the best...
From
citysearch.com on
6/11/2005
Report as offensive
|
|
You always have a great time
The service is very friendly, but professional. The food is just amazing and a great value. I come in every time I come to the city and can never get ...
From
menupages.com on
5/6/2005
Report as offensive
|
|
Great neighborhood restaurant
Great little place, kind of dark and cozy inside and a few tables outside when the weather starts to get nice. Everyone's ultra friendly, and the food...
From
menupages.com on
4/21/2005
Report as offensive
|
|
What a Gem!
Recently dined here with a party of four on an impromptu trip to the City. Not knowing where we would eat before taking in a show at the Beacon Theatr...
From
menupages.com on
3/9/2005
Report as offensive
|
|
Simply the best in food and service
Pappardella was the first restaurant my girlfriend and I ate at when we moved here...and we just keep coming back at least twice a month. The food is ...
From
menupages.com on
1/24/2005
Report as offensive
|
|
Not up to my expectations
I think this restaurant is overrated. The staff is friendly and they have good selection of italian menu but the way food is prepared is not very good...
From
menupages.com on
11/8/2004
Report as offensive
|
|
Service is Excellent!
I went to this restaurant with my girlfriend, and we both commented that the place seemed completely over-staffed. There were five people working the ...
From
menupages.com on
10/30/2004
Report as offensive
|
|
Why is there still competition?
I was walking up Columbus Ave. with my girlfriend not knowing exactly where to get a bite to eat. I had just about given up hope when this restaurant ...
From
menupages.com on
10/29/2004
Report as offensive
|
|
Comfortable neighborhood place
I happened upon this restaurant one cold, rainy night when it just looked too warm and inviting to pass up. The service here is always friendly. The f...
From
citysearch.com on
10/7/2004
Report as offensive
|
|
best italian on the upper west side
the food was incredible and the waiters/waitresses and manager were all very kind and helpful. the food came fresh and hot and obviously homemade from...
From
menupages.com on
6/9/2004
Report as offensive
|
|
Feel Good Italian
This place is simply enjoyable. The food is delicious, yet reasonable. The atmosphere is probably the best part. Very comforting and makes you feel at...
From
menupages.com on
5/27/2004
Report as offensive
|
|
Delicious and Lovely
It's amazing how many italian restaurants in the city can screw up Italian food, and this is all the more a reason to keep coming back to Pappardella ...
From
citysearch.com on
4/21/2004
Report as offensive
|
|
Very dependable italian
This restaurant is a bit overlooked on a street with many ecclectic and varied menus. But Pappardello is a very good, dependable and fairly priced ita...
From
menupages.com on
3/4/2004
Report as offensive
|
|
Perfecto!
The service here is extraordinary! I have no idea of what that one user was talking about when they said that 'it lacked' or something, because all of...
From
citysearch.com on
9/19/2003
Report as offensive
|
|
Delicious....
I love this restaurant. The cold antipasta is great and they serve the best gnocci in Manhattan! It is cooked perfectly... slightly al dente. The food...
From
citysearch.com on
7/5/2003
Report as offensive
|
|
Standard Italian
Nice decor with good pasta dishes. Stick with the basics. Service lacks....
From
citysearch.com on
3/4/2003
Report as offensive
|
|
Intimate Italian !
I had a tremendously intimate dinner with my girlfriend last Thursday at Pappardella. In fact, our evening went so well, that I just had to write abou...
From
citysearch.com on
12/23/2002
Report as offensive
|
|
Averagella
Deco was very nice. The service and food did nothing to set itself apart from the numerous other neighborhood Italian restaurants....
From
citysearch.com on
9/23/2002
Report as offensive
|